How to Get an Unresponsive Prospect Talking – and Make a Sale

If you have been rejected by a prospect initially, you may make the mistake of giving up too soon or trying to oversell. Both giving up and overselling can be quite damaging to a sales relationship. In order to get a unresponsive prospect to talk to you, you have to follow up in the right way.

Let’s discuss how to follow up with unresponsive prospects like a human being, and develop a relationship that will help you to get that prospect talking, set meetings, begin discussions, and eventually make a sale.

Don’t Talk About Past Interactions

Avoid discussing past conversations. Don’t send an email like “I’m just following up on our 2:30 call last Tuesday.” Your prospect will feel like you’re guilting them, especially if it has been a while since you last talked to them. Putting them in a defensive state will make them less likely to want to talk to you.

Reach out and try to reestablish your rapport. Talk to them about their pain points and them how you can provide a solution. It can help to remind the prospect why they wanted to talk to you in the first place; maybe they have been unresponsive because of the underlying issue you can help with.

Vary Your Contact Attempts

One mistake some salespeople make is always contacting a prospect at the same time. Chances are, calling at 3:00 PM won’t work the fifth time if it didn’t work the first time. Use a combination of voicemails, text messages, phone calls, and emails, and vary the time of day you send a message. It may be that you’ve just gotten unlucky and you keep missing the right time to talk to a prospect.

Be Human, And Be Genuine

Do your best to avoid canned phrases and sales terms. Appeal to a prospect on a human level. Do you know something about their personal life? Maybe they’re a big soccer fan – try talking to them about the latest Premier League match!

People respond better to openness and honesty than they do canned, template emails – so this may be just what you need to get a real conversation started.

Open Up A Conversation With Someone Else At The Organization

If all else fails, don’t worry. Chances are that you have more than one potential lead at the organization. Send a final email to your prospect, and ask for a follow-up. If they don’t answer, you can assume they aren’t interested – and you can move on to someone else in their company.

You’re not always going to succeed at getting an unresponsive prospect to talk to you. But with these tips, you can avoid common missteps – and maximize your chances of success.

Let's Talk

We specialize in making those who partner with us look very smart, whether that’s to the board or your business colleagues. Speaking of that, smart growth shouldn’t cost $35,000/month. An engagement with us is on an ongoing monthly basis and can range from $3,900 to $7,900/month. Each engagement is custom to your needs. The good news? From strategy to ongoing execution, we’re there every step of the way.

We guarantee an ROI on our annual engagements.

If you’re interested in what you could expect each month, fill out the form below, share how we can help, check “send the sample,” and we’ll send you what our $7,900/month engagement looks like.


The Sales & Marketing World Moves Fast.

Don’t fall behind. Our Insider Newsletter keeps you up-to-date on the latest in sales, marketing, and customer acquisition.